
You mess up. Big time.
David Karp, the 20-something founder and CEO of Tumblr, recently made a decision heard -- and disliked -- around the internet to disable five Tumblr blogs that he felt "disrupted" his community. Karp writes why he felt his hasty actions were acceptable on his own Tumblr blog:
"Accounts with the sole or primary purpose of repeatedly harassing or abusing specific members or groups within the Tumblr community will be suspended."
It's not clearly explained what constitutes harassment, so obviously it's up to the discretion of the Tumblr staff to de-activate a blog not to their liking. What's also interesting is that all five blogs "harassed" only one member of the community -- Julia Allison -- the annoying, irrelevant “microcelebrity egoblogger" who "lifecasts" along with a pair of equally dimwitted friends, Mary Rambin and Meghan Asha. Allison is also a close, personal friend of David Karp.
Personally, I believe that these ladies deserve every ounce of harassment they received. They have chosen to make their profession "people that live in public" -- and if you are a public figure, you have to expect to be exposed to scrutiny, misunderstanding and hatred. Not to mention, the girls, probably for publicity sake, like to discuss highly controversial topics on their blog. For example, my favorite was when
Mary Rambin compared a woman's right to have an abortion with her right to plastic surgery. I can't really say much else about that blog post except that I was walking around New York, angry for days. She gave women everywhere a bad name and it irks me to no end that Rambin has a large platform to share her terrible ideas. What is also interesting is that she didn't even stand by her own writing. I recently went to her site to find the post, and it was deleted.
If every blog in the world followed Karp's policies, they would all be shut down. Perez Hilton? Forget about it! Gawker? Nope -- wouldn't make it. The Kid in the Back? Gasp -- gone!
You can't ask for a public platform and then pick and choose the repercussions that go along with it. Julia Allison and David Karp are public friends, which also does not bode well for Karp's argument that Tumblr is a community as well as a blogging platform. I haven't seen him take any other "community" actions for other members of his company. Not to mention, where is the line between "community" and "free speech?" Sure, Tumblr is a private company, but in the name of a friend and not the community as a whole -- when you start mandating your own take on constitutional rights -- as well as the basic concept of the internet -- you're playing with fire.
Sadly, this whole experience makes me want to shut down my Tumblr account and no longer support the platform. Mostly because I dislike the
NonSociety girls so much, that I don't want to be associated with a business that has an exclusive relationship with their group. And mostly because I hate double standards.
Will I actually do this? Probably not. Karp has developed a very interesting platform that I like using and feel has great potential. Let's just hope that he grows up, starts making decisions like a real adult and doesn't screw it up.
More on this:
"Enforcing Manners, Tumblr Shuts Down Five Blogs" - NY Times